Newsflash: If you’re diabetic, one little piece of Halloween candy will NOT kill you!

diabetes halloween candy

Well, it probably won’t.

Based on my daring Halloween candy test (below) … YES, you can eat a little Halloween candy without dying immediately. Stress on A LITTLE!

So here’s what I did … I brought a bunch of Halloween candy from America to my coworkers in Korea. And I saved one piece each for myself: Almond Joy, Hershey’s, Kit Kat, and Reese’s.

Did I eat all four pieces of Halloween candy at once? No, because I’m not an idiot. I ate one piece of each in isolation. I wanted to see if any one of them would cause my blood sugar to go bonkers.

diabetes halloween candy fun size almond joy

Almond Joy – Blood sugar reading before eating: 112

This reading of 112 was in the morning.

Blood sugar reading after eating: 156

This reading was about an hour after I finished my little, tiny Almond Joy.

Considering how tiny that candy bar was, 156 is actually pretty high. It’s not outrageous, but it’s definitely up there.


diabetes halloween candy fun size hersheys

Hershey’s – Blood sugar reading before eating: 127

This reading of 127 was in the afternoon, a couple hours after lunch.

Blood sugar reading after eating: 125

This reading was about an hour after I finished eating that little, tiny Hershey’s. So … my blood sugar went DOWN? Hm. That’s weird.


diabetes halloween candy fun size kit kat

Kit Kat – Blood sugar reading before eating: 133

This reading of 133 was in the afternoon, a few hours after lunch.

Blood sugar reading after eating: 137

This reading was about an hour after I finished my Kit Kat. Basically no change!


diabetes halloween candy fun size reeses

Reese’s – Blood sugar reading before eating: 109

This reading of 109 was in the afternoon, a few hours after lunch.

Blood sugar reading after eating: 122

This reading was about an hour after I finished my Reese’s. Once again, I was pleasantly surprised at how little my blood sugar went up.


So, can we conclude that Halloween candy is safe to eat? Haha probably not. It’s interesting that I got such a big increase (112 → 156) from Almond Joy in the morning, but my blood sugar barely changed after eating other candy in the afternoon.

I think the big takeaway here is that moderation makes just about all things possible. And maybe I’ll repeat this test next Halloween, but I’ll mix up the times for various candies.